Coverage Explained

Commercial Crime Coverage for a Drywall Business, Explained

Commercial crime coverage pays a drywall business for money, checks and property lost to dishonesty: an employee who steals, an outsider who forges or washes a check, cash taken on the way to a supply run, a thief inside your bank account, counterfeit bills, and, by endorsement, a crew member’s theft from a client.

Why the property policy stops at an employee’s dishonesty

A property policy is written for physical loss to the shop and what it holds, not for dishonesty by the people you trust with the checkbook, so theft by your own staff needs coverage of its own.

North Carolina’s state risk-management page on employee dishonesty and computer fraud, written for that state’s own master crime policy, calls employee dishonesty coverage “the one type of crime insurance that nearly every organization needs, since employee dishonesty losses are excluded from coverage under virtually all commercial property policies.” It goes on: “For this reason, it is probably the single most important type of crime coverage.” The commercial property page shows where a break-in at the shop is answered and where an inside job is handed off; this post starts at that hand-off. Tools taken from a van or a jobsite by an outsider are a different question, and the tools and equipment page answers it.

Insuring agreements you choose one at a time

A crime policy is a set of separate insuring agreements, and under the standard crime forms as commonly written, only the agreements with a limit shown on the declarations apply.

The agreements a drywall business is most likely to see are employee theft; forgery or alteration; theft of money and securities inside the premises; robbery or safe burglary of other property inside the premises; money and securities outside the premises; computer fraud; funds transfer fraud; and money orders and counterfeit money. A policy sold as crime coverage may carry only employee theft. Each agreement can also carry its own deductible, which the post on deductibles for drywall contractor policies takes up.

Employee dishonesty coverage and fidelity bond are older names for the same employee-theft core. A license or permit bond is something else, a surety’s promise to the state or a customer, and the post on licensed, bonded and insured explains it. If the shop is insured under a business owners policy, ask whether any crime agreement is attached rather than assuming one is.

Employee theft: the bookkeeper, the checkbook and the cash deposit

Employee theft is the core agreement. Under the standard crime forms as commonly written, it pays for money, securities and other property stolen by an employee acting alone or with others, it treats forgery by that employee as theft, and it does not require you to name which employee did it.

In a drywall office that means a bookkeeper writing checks to a supplier that does not exist, padding piece-rate payroll with a name nobody hired, or keeping a homeowner’s cash deposit off the books.

The agreement has edges worth knowing before a loss tests them:

  • Who counts as an employee. The definition reaches people you pay and direct, and leaves out independent contractors. Tapers and hangers you pay as subcontractors may sit outside it as worded; whether they are legally employees is a separate question the workers’ compensation page takes up.
  • Owners and partners. Theft by you, your partners or the members of your company is excluded.
  • Known thieves. Coverage for an employee ends once you learn of that person’s dishonesty, and a loss by someone you already knew had stolen before the policy began is excluded.
  • Proof. A loss shown only by an inventory count or a profit-and-loss comparison is generally excluded, accounting errors are not theft, and income you would have earned is not covered.

Real-World Scenario: A drywall contractor’s office manager handles supplier bills, payroll and the bank deposits. When a board supplier puts the account on credit hold, the owner finds that payments the books show as made never reached the supplier. A review turns up checks written to a supplier name that does not exist, signed by the office manager and deposited to an account she controls. The owner reports it to the police and the insurer. Whether the employee theft agreement answers, and for which periods, turns on the policy version, when the loss was discovered and the wording. A shortage of board on the yard count that she also blamed on theft is a harder question, because a loss shown only by a count is generally excluded.

Forged and washed checks from outside the office

When someone outside the business forges or alters a check you wrote, or a check drawn on your account, the forgery or alteration agreement is the one asked. Forgery there means signing another person’s name to deceive; an employee who forges a check falls under employee theft instead.

The U.S. Postal Inspection Service describes check washing plainly: “Check washing scams involve changing the payee names and often the dollar amounts on checks and fraudulently depositing them.” It adds: “Occasionally, these checks are stolen from mailboxes and washed in chemicals to remove the ink.” A drywall business mailing checks to its board and compound suppliers fits the pattern; the usual sign is a supplier calling about an unpaid invoice your bank shows as cashed.

The Postal Inspection Service tells victims to “File a report with the Postal Inspection Service, your local police department, and your credit reporting bureau.” Call your bank at once, keep the image of the cashed check, and notify your insurer or agent the same day.

Cash in the office and cash on the way to a supply run

Money stolen inside the premises and money stolen while someone is carrying it are separate agreements, and under the standard crime forms as commonly written, the premises means the interior of the building you occupy for the business, not a jobsite or a van.

The outside agreement protects money and securities in the care of a messenger, which the forms define as you, a relative, a partner or member, or an employee carrying the property outside the premises. A crew lead robbed of cash on the way to a supply house fits that wording. Cash left overnight in an unattended van does not obviously fit either agreement, and the wording decides. The vehicle itself is excluded from these agreements and belongs with commercial auto.

Inside the office, the premises agreement reaches money and securities stolen by someone present there, or destroyed or vanished, and a companion agreement reaches robbery or safe burglary of other property. Recording who carries money, and when, makes a claim provable.

A hacked bank login, and a payment your own office was talked into

Computer fraud and funds transfer fraud answer when a thief moves your money without you. A payment your own staff sends because a fake email told them to is a different loss, and the base agreements may not reach it.

North Carolina’s page describes the second agreement this way: “Funds transfer fraud coverage pays for loss of money and securities resulting from fraudulent use of a bank’s funds transfer system, in which a thief purporting to be the insured instructs the bank to transfer funds from the insured’s account, using the agreed-upon methods, codes, and passwords.” Computer fraud is the companion agreement for property moved out of the premises or a bank by fraudulent use of a computer.

North Carolina also explains why employee theft does not reach it: “The employee who makes the transfer is acting in good faith, so it is not employee dishonesty.” And: “The fraud is committed by an outsider who is impersonating a manager or high level employee.” Cover for that loss is often added by endorsement or written into an insurer’s own crime form; read the wording before you rely on it.

How these scams reach a drywall office, and the first calls to make, belong to the post on cyber insurance for drywall contractors. Report a hacked login or a diverted payment to the FBI’s Internet Crime Complaint Center, whose reports can help the FBI, “in some cases, even freeze stolen funds.”

Counterfeit bills and bad money orders from a cash-paying customer

The money orders and counterfeit money agreement pays when you accept, in good faith and in exchange for your services, a money order that is not paid or counterfeit currency taken in the regular course of business. A patch-and-paint job settled in cash is where a drywall business meets it.

The Federal Reserve is blunt about the bill itself: “A counterfeit note cannot be exchanged for a genuine one, and it is illegal to knowingly pass counterfeit currency.” Its instruction is to “Store the suspect counterfeit apart from genuine currency and release it as soon as possible to law enforcement authorities.” It also warns that “Counterfeit detection pens are not always accurate and may give you false results”.

Under the standard crime forms as commonly written, the duties after a loss include notifying the police where a law may have been broken, so report the bill when it is found, with a note of the job.

When a crew member steals from the homeowner: the clients’ property endorsement

Employee theft covers property you own, lease or hold for others. A homeowner’s jewelry or a general contractor’s equipment is usually none of those, so theft by your crew from a client generally needs an endorsement.

The Clients’ Property endorsement (CR 04 01 05 06, the edition we read) adds that cover. It reads: “We will pay for loss of or damage to ‘money’, ‘securities’ and ‘other property’ sustained by your ‘client’ resulting directly from ‘theft’ committed by an identified ‘employee’, acting alone or in collusion with other persons.” It defines the term narrowly: “‘Client’ means any entity for whom you perform services under a written contract.” And it limits who benefits: “However, this insurance is for your benefit only. It provides no rights or benefits to any other person or organization, including your ‘client’.”

Note the word identified: the base employee-theft agreement does not require you to name the thief, but this endorsement does. A job with no written contract may fall outside the client definition.

Some owners ask for this in the contract. Oregon’s state risk-management guidance on crime protection and employee dishonesty coverage warns its agencies that “If the employee dishonesty coverage is not specifically endorsed to include a third-party coverage then, in most cases, it will not be comprehensive enough to provide coverage for a claim for theft by your contractor or their employees that results in a loss for your agency.” That is a public owner’s rule, not one for private jobs, but property managers and commercial clients can write similar clauses. Letting a thief go raises the separate exposure the post on employment practices liability covers.

Discovery or loss sustained: when the theft is found versus when it happened

Crime coverage comes in a discovery version and a loss-sustained version, and the difference decides which policy answers a theft that ran for a long time before anyone noticed.

A discovery version generally answers a loss discovered while the policy is in force, whenever the theft took place, subject to its wording. Discovery there means the point when you first learn facts that would lead a reasonable person to assume a covered loss has happened or will happen, not the day the full amount is known. The loss-sustained version is keyed to when the loss was sustained, and its own terms decide how an older theft is treated.

Slow embezzlement is where this matters most, and so is switching versions at renewal; the forms carry conditions meant to bridge that change, so ask before you move. The post on occurrence and claims-made coverage explains how a trigger works on liability policies.

Sizing the limits and getting ready for a quote

The limit on each agreement should match what a dishonest person could reach before anyone noticed.

Oregon’s guidance gives a starting point: “As a baseline limits should equal or exceed the maximum amount of cash or negotiable securities or vulnerable property at risk at any time.” It adds that larger limits make sense when a dishonest employee would have repeated chances to steal before the loss came to light.

For a quote, have answers ready: who signs checks, who reconciles the bank statements, whether payment changes are confirmed by phone, how cash moves, and whether any contract asks for clients’ property cover. Crime coverage sits beside the rest of a drywall program, and the drywall contractor insurance page shows how the pieces fit. We place drywall businesses in the states where we are licensed; read who we are first if you like, then send your current declarations for a quote and a licensed agent will read which agreements you carry.

Matching a loss to the crime agreement that reads it

What happened

  • Bookkeeper writes checks to a fake supplier
  • A mailed supplier check is washed and cashed
  • Supply-run cash taken from the crew lead
  • A stranger logs into the bank and wires money out
  • Office pays a fake new account from an email
  • A customer pays in counterfeit bills
  • A crew member takes a homeowner’s property

The agreement it is usually read under

  • Employee theft, including an employee’s forgery
  • Forgery or alteration
  • Outside the premises, cash with a messenger
  • Funds transfer fraud
  • Impersonation cover, only if added
  • Money orders and counterfeit money
  • Clients’ property endorsement, identified employee
Where a crime loss is usually read; only agreements with a limit on your declarations apply, and the wording decides each claim.

A side-by-side comparison. The left column lists what happened: a bookkeeper writing checks to a supplier that does not exist, a check mailed to a supplier that is washed and cashed by a stranger, cash for a supply run taken from a crew lead, a stranger logging into the bank and wiring money out, the office paying a fake new account named in an email, a customer paying in counterfeit bills, and a crew member taking a homeowner’s property. The right column lists, in the same order, the agreement each is usually read under: employee theft, which includes forgery by an employee; forgery or alteration; outside the premises, for money in a messenger’s care; funds transfer fraud; impersonation cover, only if it was added; money orders and counterfeit money; and the clients’ property endorsement, which requires an identified employee. No figures are shown.

Frequently asked questions

Our bookkeeper was taking money for a long time before we caught it. Does a crime policy reach back before we bought it?

It can, depending on the version. A discovery version generally answers a loss discovered while it is in force, even if the theft began earlier, subject to its wording. A loss-sustained version is keyed to when the loss was sustained, so earlier years may sit with earlier policies. Either way, a person you already knew had stolen before the policy began is usually excluded. Bring the bank records and the policy history to us.

Isn’t employee theft already covered by our property policy?

Usually not. Property coverage is written for physical loss to the shop and what it holds, and dishonesty by the people you employ is excluded from virtually all commercial property policies, as North Carolina’s state risk-management page puts it. That is why employee theft is the agreement most crime programs start with. A break-in by a stranger is a different question, and the commercial property page answers it.

Does employee theft coverage reach a taper we treat as a subcontractor?

Probably not as the standard crime forms are commonly written. The employee definition reaches people you pay and direct, and it leaves out independent contractors, so a hanger or taper you treat as a subcontractor may sit outside it. Whether that person is legally your employee is a separate question that payroll, tax and workers’ compensation rules answer. If your crew includes people paid that way, ask how the policy defines employee before a loss tests it.

Our office paid a supplier’s new bank account from an email that turned out to be fake. Will commercial crime pay?

Not automatically. When your own staff, deceived, sends the payment, the instruction to the bank is genuinely yours, which the base computer fraud and funds transfer fraud agreements may not reach. Cover for an employee tricked by an impersonator is often added by endorsement or written into an insurer’s own crime form, with its own conditions. Read that wording, and see the cyber post for what to do first when a payment goes astray.

If we catch an employee stealing and decide to keep them on, are we still covered for that person?

Generally not. Under the standard crime forms as commonly written, coverage for an employee ends once you, or an officer not involved in the theft, learn of that employee’s theft or other dishonest act, whenever it happened. A later theft by the same person would likely go unanswered. Keeping someone on is a business decision, but move the checkbook, the deposits and the supplier accounts to someone else, and tell us before renewal.

Is a fidelity bond the same thing as commercial crime insurance?

Often the names describe the same core. Employee dishonesty coverage and fidelity bond are older names for protection against employee theft, which is now usually one insuring agreement inside a crime policy. A license or permit bond is a different instrument: a surety’s promise to someone else, such as the state or a customer, and the surety expects to be repaid. The licensed, bonded and insured post explains that bond.

What sets the right crime coverage limit for a drywall business?

Enough to cover what a dishonest person could reach before anyone noticed. Oregon’s risk-management guidance sets a baseline at the most cash, securities or vulnerable property at risk at any time, and suggests more where a dishonest employee would have repeated chances before discovery. For a drywall office that means the bank balances one person can move, the cash a crew lead carries, and how often anyone reconciles the accounts.