On an occurrence policy, the policy in force when the injury or damage happens answers the claim, however late the claim arrives. On a claims-made policy, the policy in force when the claim is first made answers, and only for work after its retroactive date. Most drywall general liability runs on occurrence; professional and pollution policies often run claims-made.
The trigger decides which policy year answers a claim
Every liability policy has a trigger, the event that decides which policy period a claim belongs to. For a drywall business that renews every year, it tells you whether this year’s policy or an earlier one is asked to respond.
Any drywall claim carries three dates, and they are rarely the same. There is the day the crew hung and finished the work, the day something went wrong (a ceiling sagged, water reached a wall, a joint opened), and the day a demand letter or lawsuit arrived. An occurrence policy keys on the middle date. A claims-made policy keys on the last one, then looks back toward the first through its retroactive date.
The difference shows when time separates those dates and something changes in between: a new insurer, a different form, the sale of the business. This post takes up timing only. What completed work your general liability covers is on the general liability page, and which of your policies a failed ceiling reaches is on the drywall contractor insurance hub.
Occurrence: the policy in force when the damage happens
Under the standard ISO form as commonly written, a drywall contractor’s general liability is an occurrence policy, so the policy year in which the injury or damage takes place is the one that answers.
The Commercial General Liability Coverage Form (CG 00 01 04 13, the edition we read) applies only if “The ‘bodily injury’ or ‘property damage’ occurs during the policy period”, and only if an occurrence caused it. The form defines that word as “an accident, including continuous or repeated exposure to substantially the same general harmful conditions”. It carries no retroactive date and no extended reporting period, and it does not need them: the date of the damage does the sorting.
The Texas Department of Insurance’s guide to commercial general liability says the same thing in plain words: “Occurrence policies cover claims arising from injury or damage occurring while the policy is in force, regardless of when the claim is first made.”
For a drywall business, the claim lands where the damage did. Picture a wall hung under policy A, a ceiling that lets go during policy C, and a demand letter that arrives during policy D. Under an occurrence trigger, policy C is the one asked first, even if it was written by an insurer you left long ago. Keep old policies, or at least their declarations and forms schedules, for that reason.
The commercial drywall page answers what a subcontract asks when completed-operations coverage must stay in place after the building opens. The trigger is why that promise is kept by renewing without a gap: late damage is answered by whatever policy is in force when it happens, and a lapse leaves it with no policy year.
Damage that keeps going after a renewal
When damage starts during one policy period and continues into the next, the standard form generally keeps it with the policy in force when it began, provided no one responsible for reporting it knew of it beforehand.
The CG 00 01 04 13 form says damage that occurs during the policy period, and was not already known, “includes any continuation, change or resumption of that ‘bodily injury’ or ‘property damage’ after the end of the policy period.” It also works from the other side. Damage that certain insureds or authorized employees knew about before a policy began is treated as known, along with its continuation, so the later policy does not pick it up. Damage counts as known when, among other things, one of them receives a demand or claim for it.
A slow leak behind a finished wall, moisture working into board over several seasons, or a crack that keeps reopening as a building moves can all straddle renewals. Which policy year the damage began in is a question of fact, and long-running damage is not sorted the same way everywhere. What you control is notice: report a problem when you learn of it. How notice and the rest of a claim work is the subject of the post on handling an insurance claim.
Claims-made: the policy in force when the claim is made
A claims-made policy answers a claim first made while it is in force, and only for injury, damage or a wrongful act that falls after the policy’s retroactive date.
Massachusetts’ insurance regulator, in guidance to insurers writing claims-made general liability, defines claims-made coverage as answering for injury or damage “arising only out of such incidents where the first notice of a claim is made during the policy period or any extended reporting period”. The same definition reaches damage before the policy’s effective date, so long as it falls after the retroactive date. The Texas guide adds the consequence: claims from events or reports outside the policy period are not covered “unless special coverage is purchased or arranged with the insurer.”
The NAIC’s glossary of insurance terms gives a shorter definition, in which both the triggering event and the claim must fall within the policy term. That shorthand leaves out the retroactive date, which is how a claims-made policy reaches back before its own term.
For a drywall contractor, a claims-made policy looks backward from today: advice on a job finished long ago, or a spill on a site left seasons back, is answered by the policy you hold when the claim arrives. Why that timing weighs so heavily on professional work is covered in the post on professional liability for drywall contractors; the mechanics below apply to any claims-made line.
The retroactive date sets how far back a claims-made policy reaches
The retroactive date is the earliest point a claims-made policy looks back to: work or damage before it is outside the policy, however promptly the claim is reported.
The Texas guide explains that prior-acts coverage “is provided by establishing a ‘retroactive date’ covering injury or damage occurring after the retroactive date.” It says the date “usually appears in the declarations page accompanying your policy”, and that “It may be the effective date of the policy or an earlier date.” It also sets a limit: “Prior acts coverage does not cover claims that were known at the time your policy began.”
Massachusetts goes further in its rules for insurers, and they are one state’s rules, not a national standard. There, a claims-made general liability policy must carry “a mandatory endorsement that specifies a retroactive date for the policy”. Once that date is set, “it may be advanced only with the written consent of the named insured.” And when coverage expands mid-term, “If a new operation or location is added to the policy, the retroactive date for that new operation or location shall be the effective date that such new operation or location was added to the policy.”
That last rule has a drywall reading. A contractor who adds commercial ceiling work or a new shop to a claims-made policy mid-term may find the new piece starts with a fresh retroactive date. Elsewhere, the policy wording decides, so read the endorsement that adds the operation.
Tail coverage when a claims-made policy ends
When a claims-made policy ends, claims about earlier work need somewhere to go: tail coverage from the old insurer, or prior-acts coverage from the new one that carries the retroactive date forward.
The Texas guide describes tail coverage as the part that “pays for residual claims made after your policy expires.” Its advice for the moment a policy stops is direct: if a claims-made policy expires, cancels or nonrenews, “you should purchase either run-off coverage from your previous insurer or prior acts coverage from your new insurer to prevent coverage gaps.”
Many claims-made forms include a short automatic reporting window, and a longer tail is usually something you buy. Its length, cost and election deadline vary by policy and state, so read that provision before the policy ends.
Massachusetts also counts more than cancellation as an ending. Its guidance treats a change at renewal as a termination of coverage when it is a “decrease in limits, reduction of coverage, increased deductible or self-insured retention, new exclusion, or any other change in coverage less favorable to the insured.” In that state, a narrowed renewal can carry tail rights of its own. Elsewhere, ask the question before accepting the narrower terms.
Why your liability policies may not share a trigger
A drywall contractor can carry an occurrence general liability policy and claims-made professional or pollution coverage in the same year, because regulators treat claims-made as the exception for general liability and the norm for some other lines.
Massachusetts’ guidance records that, before it was issued, that state accepted general liability filings only on an occurrence basis. Connecticut’s insurance department, in its filing review checklist for claims-made policies, limits claims-made coverage to listed lines, among them errors and omissions, professional liability, “Pollution and Environmental Impairment Liability” and “Products and Completed Operations Liability”, and permits claims-made general liability only for very large businesses. Neither document explains why. The common understanding is that these lines can see a long, uncertain lag between the act and the claim.
Contractors professional and contractors pollution policies are written on each carrier’s own form, so the trigger and retroactive date are whatever that policy says; the post on contractors pollution liability for drywall work takes up that line. If an umbrella policy sits over your program, keeping the underlying policies in force is part of the same continuity.
The moments that open a gap in the timeline
Most trigger gaps open at a change, not in an ordinary renewal year: a switch of insurer, a switch of form, new work added mid-term, or the end of the business.
On a claims-made line, switching insurers is the riskiest moment, because the new policy may take its own effective date as the retroactive date. Moving from claims-made to occurrence leaves old work with nowhere to go unless you buy tail, since the occurrence policy answers only damage during its own term. And closing or selling the business ends both programs: claims-made lines need tail, and damage that happens after the last occurrence policy expires is in no policy year.
Real-World Scenario: A drywall contractor carries claims-made contractors professional coverage because a design-assist subcontract required it. At renewal, a different insurer offers similar terms, and the owner switches without comparing the declarations. The new policy’s retroactive date is its own effective date, and nobody buys tail on the old policy. Later, an owner on a job finished under the old policy claims that the contractor’s recommended board and assembly caused redesign and delay. The old policy has ended, and the new one’s retroactive date falls after the advice was given. Neither is likely to answer, on the wording of either.
What to read on your declarations before each renewal
The declarations and forms schedule tell you each policy’s trigger, and a few minutes with them before every renewal or change of insurer prevent most of these gaps.
- Is each liability policy occurrence or claims-made, and does any page say so plainly?
- On each claims-made line, what is the retroactive date, and does the renewal or new quote keep it?
- What extended reporting options does each claims-made policy offer, and by when must they be elected?
- Has the renewal narrowed anything, such as a lower limit, a new exclusion or a higher deductible?
- Do any subcontracts require coverage to stay in place after the job, and does your program keep that promise without a lapse?
The residential drywall page and the commercial page show how these policies sit in each kind of work. We place drywall businesses in the states where we are licensed; read who we are first if you like. Before you switch insurers, change a claims-made form or close the business, send us your declarations for a quote and a licensed agent will read the trigger and the retroactive date with you.